Undelete issues - PCW Interactive

PCW Interactive, a selection of reader views and comments from Personal Computer World

Personal Computer World

« Laptops for the older generation | Main | Powerline distances »

Undelete issues

After much head scratching and research I bought a Netgear SC101 Nas drive and stuck two hard drives in it, giving me a shed load of storage. I then installed the software and firmware updates, attached the drives to the PCs on my network and got music and videos streaming from it.

However, the main purpose of buying the kit was to use my Nas drive as a sort of off-site storage and backup solution, which would free up countless gigabytes of data from my main PC and server.

One day, while I was sorting files out, archiving data and doing the usual spring cleaning routine, I decided that a few files were no longer needed so deleted them. I then headed for the Recycle Bin to recover the file... but it's not there.

Frantically looking around for ways of backtracking and recovering this file that I accidentally deleted, I still couldn't find that file. I downloaded several bits of software that seemed like they would do a good recovery job but, several hours later, I got a "Results = 0" message.

After contacting Netgear support, I was referred to second-line tech support. I explained my dilemma of not being able to recover a deleted file to which the response was, "Yeah, that's because once you have deleted the file, you can't get it back due to the unique file system employed on the SC101". I asked, "Ok, so have you any tools to recover deleted files?" to which the response was, "No and we aren't developing any either."

Why on earth have so many people boasted about all the benefits of Nas drives if you can't do the most fundamental operations on it such as undelete? What good is a so-called backup/storage solution if when something goes wrong you can't undo it?

This problem may not be particularly important to the average user, but for people who are data safety aware I would personally think of an alternative solution before opting for a Nas.

Danny Leonard

Comments

Matey I am 100% in agreement with you - I too am new to NAS technology and made the fatal mistake of deleting files on a Lacie 1 Terabyte Drive with the same dilema as you have expressed here - If you have a solution that you discovered in the meantime please contact me - if you do then I will likewise contact you to share my joys :-)

Posted by Alf Urbaniak | October 8, 2007 4:25 AM

I've spent a long time looking into this. The only way I've found is to remove the HD from the NAS server and attach it as a local drive to a PC. You can then run undelete software. This is obviously a hassle but if the lost document is important I think it's the only way.

Posted by Jonathan Quin | June 19, 2008 1:22 PM

Post a comment







Site credentials: About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Top of the page
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503